← Back to library

Rehearse a negotiation against a counterpart who pushes back

u/Ok_Negotiation_2587 on r/ChatGPTPromptGenius noticed ChatGPT gives in within two messages when asked to play your boss in a raise conversation. His rehearsal prompt has it argue from the other party's actual interests, ignore your confidence, concede slowly, and force you to practice real pushback.

  • OutcomePractice asking for a raise, a better rate or a refund against an AI that argues from the other side's real interests, then get a debrief on where you gave ground.
  • SetupMinutes
  • LevelStarter
  • Creditu/Ok_Negotiation_2587 on r/ChatGPTPromptGenius
View original
Works with
ChatGPTClaudeGeminiGrok

Published Oct 20, 2026Updated Oct 20, 2026AI dry run on sample input: passed Oct 20, 2026Source verified Oct 24, 2026

When should you use it?

  • Before asking for a raise, setting a freelance rate or pushing back on a bill
  • You tend to agree too quickly once someone objects

Not for: Rehearsing deception; it is for practicing honest arguments

What do you need, and what do you get?

You need

  • Who you're negotiating with and their likely concerns
  • What you want and your walk-away point
  • Any facts you'll lean on, such as market rates or your results

You get

  • A realistic back-and-forth, one reply at a time
  • A debrief: where you conceded most, your strongest argument, and a better line to use

How does it work, step by step?

  1. Fill in the blanksDescribe the other side's role and situation, your goal and your walk-away point.
  2. Run eight exchangesAnswer as you would in the room. Keep replies short.
  3. Read the debriefNote the moment you gave away the most; that is usually the habit to fix.
  4. Run it againThe poster recommends a second round, where you can hear the improvement.

The prompt

The original prompt by u/Ok_Negotiation_2587, word for word, with a link to where it was published. Below it is our adapted version with fill-in blanks, if you want it. Works in ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and others. Values in lime are placeholders.

Original prompt by u/Ok_Negotiation_2587

Word for wordby u/Ok_Negotiation_2587
I want to rehearse a negotiation. You'll play {{their\_role}}. The situation: {{situation}} What I want: {{my\_goal}} My walk-away point: {{walk\_away}}. Act as if you don't know this. Play them realistically. Argue from their actual interests, push back the way a reasonable but tough person would, and don't give in just because I sound confident or polite. Concede only when I give you a real reason to. One short reply at a time, like a real conversation. After 8 exchanges, or when I type "stop", break character and tell me: the moment I gave away the most, the argument of mine that landed best, and the one sentence I should have said instead.

Exactly as published by u/Ok_Negotiation_2587 in A negotiation rehearsal prompt that doesn't give in.

Our adapted version (optional)

Fill in the blanks (optional; the copied prompt uses your values)

Adapted prompt5 variables
Before we start, ask me three questions about the other side: their budget or constraints, what they care about most, and what they've said before. Then play {their_role} in this negotiation: {situation}. My goal: {my_goal}. Keep my limit, {walk_away}, hidden from your character.
Stay in character, reply briefly, and only move when I give a reason tied to their interests.
After {rounds} rounds or when I say 'stop', give me: my biggest concession, my strongest point, one better sentence, and one question I should have asked them.

What can go wrong?

  • The AI only knows what you tell it about the other side. Add their real constraints, such as budget cycles, or the practice will be too easy or too hard.
  • Don't read the debrief as a script. Use it to spot patterns in how you give ground.

Our take

The problem this prompt solves is real: by default, chat assistants are agreeable, so asking one to play your manager in a raise conversation produces a manager who folds immediately. That makes practice feel good and teaches nothing. The poster's fix has three smart parts. Telling the model to argue from the other side's actual interests (budget, fairness to the team) produces objections you'll really hear. Telling it not to reward tone stops it giving in because you sound sure of yourself. And hiding your walk-away point from it keeps the practice honest. The debrief is the part that changes behavior, because people rarely notice the exact sentence where they gave ground. We added a version that asks you for the other side's constraints first, since the role-play is only as realistic as the facts you give it. In our dry run, playing a made-up employee asking for a 12% raise with a manager facing a frozen budget, the original prompt pushed back on budget and team fairness for eight turns, conceded a review date only after a concrete results argument, and the debrief named the moment the 'employee' offered to wait six months unprompted.

Where the time goes back: You get a realistic practice partner in minutes instead of finding a friend willing to play a tough boss.

FAQ

Why tell it to ignore my walk-away point?
The poster's point: otherwise it negotiates as if it knows your bottom line, which no real counterpart does.
Does it work outside salary talks?
He uses it for freelance rates, car purchases, landlords and refunds, wherever the other side has interests you can argue against.

Source and credit

The original prompt on this page is by u/Ok_Negotiation_2587, shown word for word with a link to where it was published. The summary, notes and adapted version are ours.

Original
A negotiation rehearsal prompt that doesn't give in
Creator
u/Ok_Negotiation_2587 on r/ChatGPTPromptGenius
Published on
Reddit
Original date
Oct 14, 2026
License
Not openly licensed; the original prompt is shown word for word with credit and a link to the original
Originally for
ChatGPT
AI dry run
Oct 20, 2026: passed. Dry-run tested by our AI test agent on sample input. Did not fold early; the debrief identified the real concession.
AI dry run on sample data; not run with live connected accounts. The playbooks.bot test agent filled the prompt with synthetic inputs, produced the output and checked it against the page's stated outputs and guardrails.
Verified
Oct 24, 2026: source link resolves to the original, the credited creator published it, our excerpt or prompt matches it, and the license allows our use.

Are you the creator? Claim or correct this page.

More in Career & Learning

All 37 Career & Learning playbooks →

Related playbooks

Career & LearningPrompt✓ AI dry run

Compare your project plan with its fastest possible timeline

Have an AI interview you task by task about a project you keep postponing, estimate how long each task would take with no waiting at all, set that beside your real schedule, name the three largest gaps and whether each comes from waiting, approvals, hesitation or genuine effort, and give you a one-page plan to close the largest gap this week.

Credit: AI Guides (@free_ai_guides)

Minutes
Career & LearningSkill✓ AI dry run

Learn any topic with a strict Socratic tutor skill

Load Jane Street's open-source tutoring skill into Claude, ChatGPT or a coding agent so that when you ask to be taught something, it first tests what you already know, keeps a 0 to 5 level for each part of the topic, quizzes you one question at a time without handing over answers, re-tests older material by surprise, and only ends the course after a final mixed exam.

Credit: janestreet

Minutes
Career & LearningPrompt✓ AI dry run

Shortlist jobs and tailor applications honestly

Answer a few questions, get ranked listings with honest gaps, and draft tailored applications for the top few.

Credit: u/Professional-Rest138 on r/PromptEngineering

Minutes
Career & LearningRoutine✓ AI dry run

Build a calm audio news bulletin each morning

Gather balanced headlines from outlets you choose in advance, rewrite them into a brief script for the ear, voice it, and play it on a home speaker at breakfast.

Credit: u/chronicfernweh on r/homeassistant

An afternoon+