← Back to library

List every request in an email before AI drafts the reply

On r/ChatGPTPromptGenius, u/Ok_Negotiation_2587 pointed out that AI-written replies tend to accept everything the sender asked for, plus a call nobody offered. Their fix separates deciding from writing: the model lists the asks, you answer each one, and it drafts only what you approved. We show the prompt word for word with credit.

  • OutcomeBefore an assistant writes a reply, have it pull out every ask, question, deadline and assumption in the incoming email, get a yes, no or not yet from you on each, draft using only those answers, and then list each sentence in the draft that commits you to something so you can check it before sending.
  • SetupMinutes
  • LevelStarter
  • Creditu/Ok_Negotiation_2587 on r/ChatGPTPromptGenius
View original
Works with
ChatGPTClaudeGeminiGrok

Published Nov 3, 2026Updated Nov 3, 2026AI dry run on sample input: passed Nov 3, 2026Source verified Nov 3, 2026

When should you use it?

  • Client, vendor or landlord emails that pack several asks into one message
  • You draft most replies with an assistant and send them quickly
  • Messages that propose dates, extra work or a call you have not agreed to

Not for: One-line messages you can answer faster yourself; Replies that need a lawyer or manager to sign off on terms; Fully automatic sending; this method needs you to answer each item

What do you need, and what do you get?

You need

  • The email you need to answer, pasted in full
  • Your decision on each item the assistant lists

You get

  • A numbered list of every request, question, deadline and assumption
  • A reply that accepts only what you said yes to and declines or defers the rest in a plain sentence
  • A list of the sentences in the draft that commit you to anything

How does it work, step by step?

  1. Paste the prompt and the emailStart a new chat, paste the prompt, then add a line with Email: and the full message you are answering.
  2. Answer each itemReply yes, no or not yet to every line on the list, including the small asides.
  3. Read the draftCheck that nothing appears in the reply that you did not approve.
  4. Check the commitments listCompare each listed sentence with your answers and remove any promise you did not mean to make.
  5. Send it yourselfCopy the reply into your mail app and send once the list matches what you decided.

The prompt

The original prompt by u/Ok_Negotiation_2587 on r/ChatGPTPromptGenius, word for word, with a link to where it was published. Below it is our adapted version with fill-in blanks, if you want it. Works in ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and others. Values in lime are placeholders.

Original prompt by u/Ok_Negotiation_2587 on r/ChatGPTPromptGenius

Word for wordby u/Ok_Negotiation_2587 on r/ChatGPTPromptGenius
I'm going to paste an email I need to reply to. Before you write anything:

1. List every request, question, deadline or assumption in it that needs an answer from me. Include the small ones, like "could you also...", proposed times, and anything they assume I already agreed to.
2. For each item, ask me: yes, no, or not yet. Then wait for my answers.
3. Draft the reply using only my answers. Don't agree to anything I didn't say yes to. Don't offer extra help, calls or follow-ups I didn't mention. Don't end with "let me know if you need anything else."
4. For anything I said no or not yet to, decline or defer in one plain sentence, without over-apologizing.
5. Under the draft, list every sentence that commits me to something, so I can check them before I hit send.

Exactly as published by u/Ok_Negotiation_2587 on r/ChatGPTPromptGenius in When ChatGPT drafts your email reply, it quietly agrees to everything the other person asked for.

Our adapted version (optional)

Fill in the blanks (optional; the copied prompt uses your values)

Adapted prompt3 variables
I need to answer the email below from {sender}. Do not write the reply yet.

First, number every item in it that needs a decision from me: direct requests, questions, deadlines, proposed meetings, side requests and anything the sender treats as already agreed. Then stop and wait for me to mark each one yes, no or not yet.

After I answer, write the reply in {tone} using only my answers. Accept nothing I did not approve, add no offers of my own, and handle every no or not yet in a single plain sentence. Skip generic closing offers.
Below the reply, quote each sentence that commits me to an action or date.

Email:
{email_text}

What can go wrong?

  • Assumptions hide in phrases like "as we discussed". Make sure the list includes them, not only direct questions.
  • Assistants like friendly closing lines. A sign-off offering to follow up next week is a commitment too.
  • Not yet still needs a date or a reason for the other person. Add one if you have it.
  • Forwarded threads can contain old requests that no longer apply. Paste only the message you are answering.

Our take

This prompt fixes a failure most people only notice after they hit send: the friendliest-sounding reply is usually the one that agrees to everything. An assistant asked to answer an email will happily confirm a deadline you had not decided on, pull a colleague into the thread and offer a call, because that reads as helpful. Making the model list each ask and wait for your yes, no or not yet moves the decisions back to you, and the draft becomes a writing job rather than a negotiation the model holds on your behalf. The final list of committing sentences is the clever part, since it audits the draft against your own answers. Two cautions: it adds a round trip, so save it for messages with real asks, and keep reading the list carefully, because a long email can produce a long list. In our dry run with a fictional event client asking for a revised quote by Friday, a catering introduction, an assumed AV package and a Tuesday call, the draft confirmed only the quote, deferred the introduction, said AV was not included and declined the call, then listed the single sentence promising the quote by Friday.

Where the time goes back: You make the decisions once in a few short answers, and you avoid the slow cleanup that follows a polite reply that promised a deadline, a meeting or extra work you never agreed to.

FAQ

Does it work outside ChatGPT?
The author says it behaves the same in Claude, Gemini and Grok. It is plain text, so any chat assistant can run it.
Why not just ask for a short, professional reply?
According to the post, tone instructions only shorten the agreement. Splitting your decisions from the writing is what stops the draft from accepting things.
What is the final list for?
It catches promises the model adds anyway, such as a closing line about following up, even after you answered every item.

Source and credit

The original prompt on this page is by u/Ok_Negotiation_2587 on r/ChatGPTPromptGenius, shown word for word with a link to where it was published. The summary, notes and adapted version are ours.

Original
When ChatGPT drafts your email reply, it quietly agrees to everything the other person asked for
Creator
u/Ok_Negotiation_2587 on r/ChatGPTPromptGenius
Published on
Reddit
Original date
Nov 1, 2026
License
Not openly licensed; the original prompt is shown word for word with credit and a link to the original
Originally for
ChatGPT
AI dry run
Nov 3, 2026: passed. Dry-run tested by our AI test agent on sample input. All four asks found, including the assumption; draft used only the answers; no added offers; commitments list correct.
AI dry run on sample data; not run with live connected accounts. The playbooks.bot test agent filled the prompt with synthetic inputs, produced the output and checked it against the page's stated outputs and guardrails.
Verified
Nov 3, 2026: source link resolves to the original, the credited creator published it, our excerpt or prompt matches it, and the license allows our use.

Are you the creator? Claim or correct this page.

More in Operations & Admin

All 203 Operations & Admin playbooks →

Related playbooks

Operations & AdminPrompt✓ AI dry run

Draft client documents from records with no guessed facts

Have an AI draft deal reviews, timelines, requirements docs and similar client-facing documents only from your CRM, estimates, contracts and call notes, with every line traceable, conflicts between sources flagged to you, unconfirmed items labeled as open, and a person signing off before anything goes out.

Credit: Antonio Perrone

Minutes
Operations & AdminPrompt✓ AI dry run

Stress-test a business decision with an AI pre-mortem

Before committing to a price rise, launch or other big change, have an assistant assume the plan has already gone wrong, rank the likeliest causes with an early signal for each, work out how much loss you can absorb before the change stops paying, list the assumptions underneath with a cheap test for each, and then write the announcement against a scoring rubric it sets first.

Credit: Shubham Vora

Minutes
Operations & AdminPrompt✓ AI dry run

Talk through a meeting with your agent right after it ends

As soon as a client meeting, phone call or on-site visit wraps up, start a voice conversation with your agent, talk through what happened while it is fresh, and get back a written list of decisions, commitments, due dates and open questions plus a follow-up draft you check before anything is sent.

Credit: Michael Fenech (@Michael_Fenech_)

Minutes
Operations & AdminWorkflow✓ AI dry run

Run client work on projects, skills and scheduled briefs

Client context that persists, recurring research and reports that arrive on schedule, and meeting prep done before you walk in.

Credit: u/Beginning-Willow-801 on r/ManusOfficial

An afternoon+
Customer SuccessPrompt✓ AI dry run

Send your buyer a phone-friendly list of contract deadlines

Give the ratification date and the key contingency deadlines and get a friendly email to your buyer that lists each date in order, says what happens at each step and what the buyer must do.

Credit: David Stroh

Minutes