← Back to library

Challenge an uninsured hospital bill using Medicare rates

Matt Rosenberg's brother-in-law died uninsured after a heart attack and the hospital billed $195,628. Rosenberg got the coded UB-04 claim form, had Claude price each code at Medicare rates and spot billing-rule problems, checked the work with ChatGPT and the rules himself, and settled at about $32,500.

  • OutcomeTurn an opaque hospital bill into a line-by-line comparison with what Medicare would pay, then negotiate from that number with a written, rule-based argument.
  • SetupUnder an hour
  • LevelIntermediate
  • CreditMatt Rosenberg
View original
Works with
ClaudeChatGPT

Published Oct 23, 2026Updated Oct 23, 2026AI dry run on sample input: passed Oct 23, 2026Source verified Oct 23, 2026

When should you use it?

  • You or a family member got a large bill without insurance coverage
  • The bill lists vague categories instead of procedures
  • You are willing to negotiate in writing

Not for: Replacing legal counsel; the author explicitly advises against it; Bills already settled by an insurer under its contract

What do you need, and what do you get?

You need

  • The itemized bill and the UB-04 claim form with procedure codes
  • Date and location of service
  • Any correspondence from the hospital

You get

  • A spreadsheet of codes with Medicare payment amounts and notes
  • A list of billing-rule problems such as bundled items charged separately
  • A detailed letter offering a specific settlement amount

How does it work, step by step?

  1. Ask for the coded claimRequest the itemized bill, then the UB-04 form the hospital would send an insurer; internal codes alone are not enough.
  2. Price every codeAsk for a spreadsheet of each code with what Medicare pays, answering its questions on year, location and payment type.
  3. Probe the odditiesAsk why some lines show zero; bundled payments, procedures that never happened and mutually exclusive charges surface here.
  4. Get a second checkHave a different AI audit the analysis for errors, then read the cited Medicare rules yourself.
  5. Make a written offerSend a letter listing each rule issue and offering the Medicare-equivalent amount for a zero balance; expect a counter.

The prompt

Our own prompt, inspired by Matt Rosenberg and written to work in Claude and ChatGPT. Values in lime are placeholders.

Prompt0 variables
Here is a hospital claim form with procedure codes for services on [date] in [city, state]. Build a spreadsheet: code | description | hospital charge | Medicare payment for [year] in this location | note. Ask me any questions you need about payment type. Flag lines that look bundled into another payment, services that seem inconsistent with the visit, and charges that billing rules may not allow together, citing the specific rule for each so I can verify it. Then total what Medicare would have paid.

Inspired by Matt Rosenberg: I used Claude to negotiate $163,000 off a hospital bill. In a complex healthcare system, AI is giving patients power.. The prompt above is written by playbooks.bot in our own words; nothing from the original is quoted.

What can go wrong?

  • Models can make things up; the author verified with a second AI and about twenty minutes of reading the actual rules.
  • Grieving families are pressured to pay quickly; ask for documents and sign nothing until you understand the bill.

Our take

Matt Rosenberg's brother-in-law died uninsured after a heart attack and the hospital billed nearly two hundred thousand dollars. Rosenberg got the coded UB-04 claim form, had Claude price each code at Medicare rates and spot billing-rule problems, checked the work with ChatGPT and the rules himself, and settled near thirty-two thousand five hundred. The leverage came from a specific benchmark, the Medicare rate for each coded service, not from asking an AI to argue vaguely. Verification habits make it repeatable: a second model checked the numbers and he read the underlying rules before relying on them. Contact medical billing advocates and hospital financial assistance programs too. Put his warning that AI is no substitute for legal counsel at the top of your notes. Ask for the itemized coded claim early. Make offers in writing. Keep copies of every calculation with sources. Do not share full medical records with tools you have not vetted for privacy.

Where the time goes back: Pricing dozens of codes and reading Medicare bundling rules would take days; the assistant made it a couple of hours of conversation plus verification.

FAQ

What did the analysis find?
Supplies and devices billed separately that Medicare covers in one bundled payment, a charge for a procedure that never happened, and a ventilation charge Medicare would not allow alongside other critical care.
How did the negotiation go?
Their opening offer was about $28,675; the hospital came back at $36,356, and both sides agreed on roughly $32,500 after three emails and a signed agreement.

Source and credit

Inspired by Matt Rosenberg. We describe the idea in our own words, link to the original, and wrote the prompt ourselves; nothing is quoted.

Inspired by
I used Claude to negotiate $163,000 off a hospital bill. In a complex healthcare system, AI is giving patients power.
Creator
Matt Rosenberg
Published on
Business Insider
Original date
Feb 13, 2026
License
Not openly licensed (the poster keeps all rights), so we quote nothing and link to the original
Originally for
Claude
AI dry run
Oct 23, 2026: passed. Dry-run tested by our AI test agent on sample input. PASS: Gates held on desk check; nothing was sent, filed, purchased or published.
AI dry run on sample data; not run with live connected accounts. The playbooks.bot test agent filled the prompt with synthetic inputs, produced the output and checked it against the page's stated outputs and guardrails.
Verified
Oct 23, 2026: source link resolves to the original, the credited creator published it, our excerpt or prompt matches it, and the license allows our use.

Are you the creator? Claim or correct this page.

More in Money & Admin

All 82 Money & Admin playbooks →

Related playbooks

Money & AdminPrompt✓ AI dry run

Appeal a parking ticket with a clear, polite letter

Turn the facts behind a parking ticket into a short, respectful appeal to the right city office, with your evidence attached.

Credit: u/Fuhdawin on r/ChatGPT

Minutes
Money & AdminPrompt✓ AI dry run

Check a contractor's charges and challenge the wrong ones

Have AI compare every invoice line and change order with your purchase orders and emails, then draft specific, evidence-based disputes.

Credit: Addicted Hoosier (@AddictedHoosier)

Under an hour
Money & AdminPrompt✓ AI dry run

Check a firm's new invoice against what you already paid

Collect the correspondence, statements and bills from a professional firm in a single place, have an assistant maintain a running ledger of what was agreed, billed and paid, and when a new invoice arrives, have it compare each line with that ledger and list possible repeats or mismatches with the documents behind them, so you can ask the firm politely before paying.

Credit: u/m_x_a on r/claude

Under an hour