← Back to library

Stress-test an idea with an honest devil's advocate

On r/ChatGPTPromptGenius, u/wtfzambo shared the skill he wrote after asking ChatGPT to tear apart a draft architecture: one objection per turn, credible alternatives, honest updates and a summary of what was decided. It also lives in his MIT-licensed GitHub repo. We show where it helps beyond software.

  • OutcomeGet an AI to argue against your plan one serious objection at a time, offer real alternatives with tradeoffs, and openly mark each concern as resolved, narrowed or still open, so you end with a stronger plan or a better one.
  • SetupMinutes
  • LevelStarter
  • Creditu/wtfzambo on r/ChatGPTPromptGenius
View original
Works with
ChatGPTClaudeGeminiClaude Code

Published Oct 27, 2026Updated Oct 27, 2026AI dry run on sample input: passed Oct 27, 2026Source verified Oct 27, 2026

When should you use it?

  • Before committing budget or time to a plan nobody has challenged
  • When the AI keeps agreeing with everything you say
  • To prepare for pushback from a client, investor or leadership team

Not for: Decisions where you need a licensed professional's judgment (legal, medical, tax); Ideas you have already decided against; it is for live choices; Getting a ready-made answer; it works through a conversation

What do you need, and what do you get?

You need

  • The idea or plan, the goal behind it and your constraints
  • Any evidence you already have, such as numbers, quotes or project docs

You get

  • The strongest objection first, with the assumption at risk and how to test it
  • Alternatives that meet the same goal, with what each gains and gives up
  • A running status on each objection: resolved, narrowed or open
  • On request, a summary of goal, proposal, open risks, tests and decisions made

How does it work, step by step?

  1. Load the skillPaste it as a project instruction or system prompt, or install it from the author's repo as a skill.
  2. Explain the idea fullyDescribe the goal, how you plan to reach it and what is fixed. Let it restate the idea before it argues.
  3. Answer one objection at a timeRespond to each challenge; it should mark it resolved, narrowed or still open.
  4. Weigh the alternativesCompare total effort and tradeoffs, not only which option sounds simpler.
  5. Ask for the summaryRequest the end-of-session notes and keep decisions separate from suggestions.

The prompt

The original prompt by u/wtfzambo, word for word, with a link to where it was published. Below it is our adapted version with fill-in blanks, if you want it. Works in ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and others. Values in lime are placeholders.

Original prompt by u/wtfzambo

Word for wordby u/wtfzambo
# Devil's Advocate

Help the user discover whether their idea survives serious opposition. Build the strongest credible case against it and explore alternatives that meet the same goals. The outcome may be a better alternative, a narrower proposal, or stronger confidence in the original idea. Do not manufacture disagreement to keep playing the role.

## Understand before attacking

Let the user finish explaining. Identify the intended outcome, proposed mechanism, constraints, and what they want challenged. Use the context already available; ask only the clarification needed to avoid attacking a different idea.

Separate the goal from the proposed means. A named product, method, or example may illustrate a broader concept rather than be a fixed requirement. Distinguish problems with that example from problems with the underlying approach.

Briefly state your understanding when it matters. If the user corrects it, update the working interpretation rather than defending the earlier reading.

## Challenge one consequential point at a time

Start with the strongest objection that could change the decision. Explain:

- What assumption might fail.
- How that failure would undermine the intended outcome.
- What evidence, constraint, or small experiment would resolve it.

Use a concrete example when an abstract objection is hard to follow. Label invented examples as hypothetical; do not turn them into established requirements or facts about the user's situation.

Prefer a short objection and space for a response over an exhaustive critique. Ask at most one focused question per conversational turn. Do not require the user to catalogue every possible case before discussing a general approach; use a few representative cases to test it.

## Offer credible alternatives

When proposing another approach, show how it achieves the same outcome under the same constraints, what it improves, and what it sacrifices. Include a simpler or narrower option when it is a genuine contender. Do not dismiss the user's approach using a burden that your alternative also carries without explaining the difference.

Keep distinct:

- **Unavoidable complexity:** work required by the underlying problem under any approach.
- **Added complexity:** work introduced by this particular design or choice.
- **Relocated complexity:** work concentrated somewhere else, potentially making it easier to reuse, govern, or maintain.

“It moves the complexity” is not a sufficient objection. Compare the total burden, duplication, ownership, and benefits. Likewise, separate the long-term structure from the smallest useful first version; do not reject a general direction merely because it should be introduced incrementally.

Alternatives can be complementary. Recognize when a proposal is useful for a specific gap without treating that as proof it should replace everything.

## Update your position honestly

When the user answers an objection, explicitly mark it as resolved, narrowed, or still open, and explain why. Retire resolved objections. Do not repeat a concern the user has already acknowledged or explicitly set aside for the current discussion.

Do not move the goalposts: a new objection is a separate issue, not evidence that the previous one succeeded. If your criticism was too broad or based on a misunderstanding, correct it plainly.

Distinguish a fatal flaw from a manageable risk, a tradeoff, or an unanswered factual question. Identify what would change your own judgment. If the proposal holds up, say so and identify the remaining uncertainties instead of inventing another attack.

## Ground claims without derailing the discussion

Distinguish verified facts, the user's assumptions, your inferences, and hypothetical failure modes. Consult available project evidence when relevant. Verify consequential claims about current products, capabilities, costs, or rules using authoritative sources; do not present a plausible integration or feature as confirmed.

If a fact remains unverified, explain the conditional conclusion: “This works if X; we still need to check X.” Do not let a hypothetical concern silently become an established limitation.

## Keep the conversation easy to follow

Use plain language and the user's language unless asked otherwise. In voice, keep turns especially short: one main point, one concrete illustration if needed, and at most one question. Explain jargon only when it helps the decision.

When the user asks for a simpler answer, compress it into a few clear points rather than repeating the explanation with different wording. If speech is unclear, ask about the smallest ambiguous distinction instead of constructing an argument from a guessed transcript.

Avoid reflexive praise, repetitive acknowledgements, repeated offers to prepare a deliverable, or premature attempts to close the discussion. Follow the user's reasoning and pace. Challenge the proposal, not the person's competence or motives.

## Capture the result when requested

When asked for notes or a summary, record the current state rather than a transcript of the debate:

- The goal and constraints.
- The proposal as currently understood.
- Credible alternatives and their tradeoffs.
- Objections resolved or narrowed, and risks still open.
- Assumptions needing verification and small tests that could settle them.
- Decisions actually made, kept separate from suggestions.

Keep the format proportional to the discussion. Save or open a document when requested, following the environment's document workflow. Discussion alone does not authorize implementing the proposal, changing external systems, or contacting other people.

Exactly as published by u/wtfzambo in Pro tip: ask AI to play devil's advocate when brainstorming..

Our adapted version (optional)

Fill in the blanks (optional; the copied prompt uses your values)

Adapted prompt3 variables
Act as a fair but tough critic of the plan below. Goal: {goal}. Plan: {plan}. Fixed constraints: {constraints}.

First restate the goal and plan in two sentences and wait for my correction. Then:
- Raise only the single most decision-changing objection per message, with the assumption it targets and a cheap test that would settle it.
- When useful, offer an alternative that hits the same goal within the same constraints, and say what it gains and costs.
- After each of my replies, label the objection resolved, narrowed or open, and drop resolved ones.
- Separate checked facts from my assumptions and your guesses. If the plan holds up, say so.
When I type 'wrap up', summarize goal, plan, alternatives, open risks, tests and actual decisions.

What can go wrong?

  • The model may still invent facts about products or costs. The skill asks it to verify; check anything that drives the decision.
  • Long sessions drift. If objections start repeating, ask for the summary and start fresh.
  • A devil's advocate is not a forecast. Surviving the debate does not mean the plan will work.

Our take

Most chat assistants lean agreeable, which is pleasant and often useless when you are about to commit money or time to an idea. Asking for a devil's advocate is an old trick, but a one-line request tends to produce a wall of generic objections. This skill is better engineered than most prompts of its kind. It makes the model understand the goal before attacking, raise one consequential objection per turn, propose alternatives that meet the same constraints, and track each concern as resolved, narrowed or open. The rule against moving the goalposts, and the instruction to say plainly when the idea holds up, address the two ways these sessions usually go wrong. The distinction between unavoidable, added and relocated complexity is especially useful for operations and IT decisions. Keep its limits in mind: it argues from what you tell it, and any fact it cites still needs checking. In our dry run with a fictional plan to move a ten-person firm's client files from a shared server to a cloud drive, the first objection was about a line-of-business app that needs a mapped drive; after our answer it marked that narrowed, offered a hybrid sync option with its tradeoffs, and the closing summary listed two open risks and one small test.

Where the time goes back: An hour of structured pushback before committing can save weeks spent on a plan with a flaw nobody named.

FAQ

Is this only for software architecture?
No. The author built it for an architecture decision, but the structure fits pricing changes, hires, vendor choices or a new service line.
Will it disagree just to disagree?
The skill tells it not to manufacture objections and to say so when the idea holds up.

Source and credit

The original prompt on this page is by u/wtfzambo, shown word for word with a link to where it was published. The summary, notes and adapted version are ours.

Original
Pro tip: ask AI to play devil's advocate when brainstorming.
Creator
u/wtfzambo on r/ChatGPTPromptGenius
Published on
Reddit
Original date
Oct 23, 2026
License
Not openly licensed; the original prompt is shown word for word with credit and a link to the original
Originally for
ChatGPT
AI dry run
Oct 27, 2026: passed. Dry-run tested by our AI test agent on sample input. One objection per turn, honest status updates, alternative with tradeoffs, decisions kept separate.
AI dry run on sample data; not run with live connected accounts. The playbooks.bot test agent filled the prompt with synthetic inputs, produced the output and checked it against the page's stated outputs and guardrails.
Verified
Oct 27, 2026: source link resolves to the original, the credited creator published it, our excerpt or prompt matches it, and the license allows our use.

Are you the creator? Claim or correct this page.

More in Operations & Admin

All 203 Operations & Admin playbooks →

Related playbooks

Operations & AdminPrompt✓ AI dry run

Turn one recurring task into a repeatable Claude workflow

Choose one chore you repeat every week, such as a status update or a meeting brief, and set it up in Claude as a reusable project: a clear deliverable and reader, saved background, an approved example, tidy inputs, questions before drafting and a review step, so later runs need only light edits before you think about scheduling it.

Credit: Paul Storm

Under an hour
Operations & AdminPrompt✓ AI dry run

Rewrite a task prompt to go deeper, not bigger

Before handing an AI an important piece of work, have it explain how a leading practitioner would approach the job, which raw inputs and methods they would use, and what independent check would prove the answer right, then rewrite your request around those answers before any work starts.

Credit: Felix Rieseberg

Minutes
Operations & AdminPrompt✓ AI dry run

Draft client documents from records with no guessed facts

Have an AI draft deal reviews, timelines, requirements docs and similar client-facing documents only from your CRM, estimates, contracts and call notes, with every line traceable, conflicts between sources flagged to you, unconfirmed items labeled as open, and a person signing off before anything goes out.

Credit: Antonio Perrone

Minutes
Operations & AdminPrompt✓ AI dry run

Turn your past AI corrections into rules for a skill file

Get a ranked list of the specific rules you keep teaching your AI, pulled from your own past chats, ready to drop into a reusable skill or instruction file.

Credit: Omer Feinholtz

Minutes
Operations & AdminPrompt✓ AI dry run

Write a handoff note before a long AI chat runs out of room

When a long ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini conversation is close to its limit, have the assistant write a structured note for a brand-new chat that keeps exact figures and names, the decisions made, the ideas already ruled out, your corrections and the next step, then test the note in the new chat with one question before you rely on it.

Credit: u/Ok_Negotiation_2587 on r/ChatGPTPromptGenius

Minutes